Skip to main content

Ray Raymond v. Territory of Washington. Motion to Quash

 

In the District Court of Washington Territory and for the Fourth Judicial District thereof holding terms at the county seat of Spokane County.

The Territory of Washington
vs.
Ray Raymond} Motion to quash

Now comes the defendant and moved the court to quash and set aside the indictment returned into court by the Grand Jury on the 20th day of March 1887 on the grounds following to wit:

1.-That it is not entitled in this court or in a court appearing to have jurisdiction to receive it.

2.- That it is not entitled in the cause in this that the place of holding court and the venue[?] of the court is not set forth.

3.- The Grand jury finding the indictment in above entitled cause was not selected drawn or empannelled as required by law in this: That the list of said Grand Jurors was drawn from an imperfect and incomplete list of persons in Spokane County qualified to serve as Grand Jurors and the list of names prepared by the County Commissioners from which said list was drawn did not contain the names of all of the persons in Spokane County qualified to serve   as Grand Jurors, and other persons in said Spokane County qualified to serve as such Grand Jurors at the time said list was prepared were omitted therefore and their names do not appear thereon and the present members composing the Grand Jury were drawn selected and drawn from such imperfect and incomplete list – 3 1/2 that no list of such persons qualified grand jurors in spokane county and was fraud by the commitment by the persons of grand jury from their defined district and was named by the county. 4. That said Grand Jury had no authority to entertain pass upon or find any indictment against defendant whatever for the reason defendant was under recognizance for her appearance at this term of court and therefore had a right to challenge the panel or any individual member thereof of which right by this action the grand jury she has been deprived.

5.- That an indictment is now pending in this court charging defendant with the crime of murder in the second degree in the killing of one James Finch upon which issue is joined and was so pending and issue joined at the time of the finding of the indictment herein by the plaintiff this for the same offense in fact.

 

6.- It appears that no effort whatever was made by said Grand Jury to discover the name of the party injured.

7.- That some of the members of said Grand Jury were disqualified to act as Grand Jurors not being citizens of the United States and some of said Grand Jurors has were so prejudiced against deft that she could not have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before them.

Griffitts Stout

N.T. Catno

J.T. Park

Atty. for Deft.

 

Filed May 23, 1887 D.A. Clement Clerk District Court

Citation

Katrina Jagodinsky, Cory Young, Andrew Varsanyi, Laura Weakly, Karin Dalziel, William Dewey, Erin Chambers, Greg Tunink. “Ray Raymond v. Territory of Washington. Motion to Quash.” Petitioning for Freedom: Habeas Corpus in the American West, 1812-1924, University of Nebraska–Lincoln. Accessed November 24, 2024. https://petitioningforfreedom.unl.edu/documents/item/hc.case.wa.0162.047

Back to top